Muffins are incredibly fun to bake. Muffins can be made hundreds of different ways and you can treat yourself and your family for breakfast, lunch, and even dinner. When you get an excellent muffin pan, you won’t want to let it go. The perfect muffin pan will cook thoroughly and evenly, your fresh-baked muffins will pop right out, and the pan will clean up within seconds.
If these sound like the features you have been looking for in a muffin pan, you are in the right place. Here are our top ten best muffin pans of 2020.
Best Muffin Pan
1. AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Muffin Pan, Set of 2, 12 Cups Each
At the top of our list is the AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Muffin Pan. This is a set of two muffin pans so that you will have twenty-four cups total. When you consider the pricing plus the fact that these are nonstick, this is truly a great deal.
The AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Muffing pans are intended to be hand-washed, so they keep their nonstick for years to come. These will be oven safe up to 500 degrees and allow you to make some great creations.
The fact that these muffin pins are made with a heavy carbon steel helps them have some extra durability, and they tend to cook more evenly as well. We found that the baking we did with these cooked very evenly and there were no inconsistencies throughout the batch.
- Great pricing for two pans
- Heavy carbon steel for durability
2. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Muffin and Cupcake Pan
Wilton is a reliable name when it comes to bakeware. This muffin pan will cook twelve at a time, and it has the nonstick, easy release coating to make cleanup very easy. Without the nonstick, you also end up having to change your recipe and incorporate more oils; this is not necessary.
Wilson is confident in their products that they sell this particular model with a ten-year warranty. One of the things we love best about the Wilson Cupcake tin is the easy to use carrying handles.
All they did was make this muffin pan a little wider on both ends. Now you can put your cupcakes in and out of the oven without feeling like you are going to drop the pan.
- Made from a high-quality steel
- Easy release nonstick coating
- Handwash or dishwasher safe as well
3. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick 6 Cup Jumbo Muffin Pan, Set of 2
Our top two muffin pan choices were capable of making twelve muffins. These Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick Muffin Pans are only capable of producing six at a time, but you do get two of them with your purchase.
The six muffins that you can make with these are jumbo muffins. Think about a warm blueberry muffin on a Saturday morning with a freshly made omelet. You know that you are going to want two or three of those things, you may as well make a jumbo one and enjoy it.
The Wilson Recipe Right Pan is made with a nonstick coating, and it is a heavy gauge construction as well. With a jumbo muffin pan, the better quality material in the pan is quite essential. Without the heavy gauge, your muffins will not cook evenly.
- Comes with two pans
- Dishwasher safe but hand wash for longevity
- Large six cup pans
4. USA Pan Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan, 12 Well, Nonstick & Quick Release Coating, Made in the USA from Aluminized Steel
The USA Pan Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan are one of the more expensive muffin pans on our list, but it is also commercial grade. This pan is made with a heavy gauge aluminized steel that gives you a complete and thorough cook on each of your muffins or cupcakes.
The USA Pans have a nonstick coating that they call “Americoat”. This will help the food to pop right out of the pan with just a bit of hot water, and a sponge your pan will be perfectly clean afterward.
The USA Pan is not new to the market, and this is a quality design that has been around for many years. If you are serious about your muffins and you want something that will hold up well over time, the USA Pan Bakeware is the way to go.
- Quality product has been around for many years
- Cooks evenly
5. 12 Cups Silicone Muffin Pan – Nonstick BPA Free Cupcake Pan 1 Pack Regular Size Silicone Mold
Coming in at the fifth spot on our list is the first Silicone option we have to share with you. If you have not yet tried cooking with a Silicone Muffin Pan, you will be surprised by the functionality of this pan for something that does not seem like it will hold up.
The silicone is naturally a nonstick surface. The muffins you create will pop out of this pan with such ease that you may start switching all of your kitchen gear to silicone.
It is also effortless to clean these up when you are finished. Amazingly the Silicone pans are also dishwasher safe.
You will have to get used to the feel and the weight of the silicone, but you will be impressed with their ability to make a thoroughly and evenly cooked muffin. The silicone will work in temperatures from 104 degrees up to 446 degrees; it has almost the same functionality as the steel.
- Dishwasher safe
- Easy to get food out
- High heat resistance
6. Keliwa’s 12 – Cup Silicone Muffin – Cupcake Baking Pan/Non – Stick Silicone Mold/Dishwasher – Microwave Safe
Next on our list is the Keliwa 12 Cup Silicone Muffin Pan. This is another Silicone pan that is BPA free and dishwasher and microwave safe. You can’t say that for all of the steel pans on our list, that is for sure.
You will need to place a Silicone pan like this on a cookie sheet before putting it directly into the oven. If you do not do this, there will be inconsistencies and potentially spills.
However, the great news is that you won’t need to spray this muffin tin with great at all. The muffins will pop right out when you are finished cooking.
The Keliwa pans come in bright colors and will make an excellent addition to any kitchen. The only small downside we saw to these is that they don’t have a lot of room to grab around the edges.
Outside of that, we love the pricing, the stain resistance, and the fact that you can fold this and it will pop right back into the proper shape.
- Priced very well
- Easy to remove muffins
- Works in microwave and dishwasher as well
7. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Mega Standard-Size Muffin and Cupcake Baking Pan, Standard 24-Cup
When you are cooking for a crowd, this is the muffin pan that you are going to need. The Wilton Perfect Results series comes in a few different sizes, but the Mega Standard Size is a true time-saver.
This is one very large muffin pan that will cook twenty-four muffins at once. The muffins are all standard size, and you will have no issues making sure that your entire crowd is well fed. Even with the size of this pan, it will fit in most standard size ovens.
The pan is made of a nonstick steel material that will quickly release each muffin when it is finished cooking. You can use this muffin pan in the dishwasher, but we recommend hand washing it to make sure that it keeps its nonstick coating for years to come.
- Nonstick coating
- High-quality steel
- Makes 24 standard cupcakes at once
8. Rachael Ray Yum -o Nonstick Bakeware 12-Cup Muffin Tin With Grips / Nonstick 12-Cup Cupcake Tin With Grips – 12 Cup, Gray
There is no questioning the fact that Rachel Ray makes some of the best-looking cookware on the market. In addition to the great looks, it also functions quite well. This 12 Cup muffin tin is made with heavy gauge steel, and it is quite sturdy.
This is a nonstick option that makes cleaning up after baking much easier than it would be otherwise. Probably our favorite feature of this particular product is the handles. The handles offer an easy grasp, and they make sure that your pan will not slip from your hands as it enters and exits the oven.
You can use the Rachel Ray pan up to 500 degrees. If you want something other than the 12 cups, there are options in both a six and a 24 cup as well.
- Food comes out easily
- Very nice handles
- Will not warp over time
9. Silicone Muffin Pan Cupcake Set – Mini 24 Cups and Regular 12 Cups Muffin Tin
If you are starting to make the change from steel to silicone, then this silicone muffin pan cupcake set could be a great choice. With this product, you are going to get a regular twelve cup muffin tin, a mini 24 cup, and 12 silicone cupcake liners as well.
As we have mentioned, the main reason to switch to the silicone is the easy release of your baked goods. No more fighting to get your muffins out in one piece.
These pans are also fun because they come in a variety of colors. Whatever your theme is in your kitchen, you will be able to match with the Silicone Muffin Pan Cupcake Set.
- Comes as a set
- Can make quite a few muffins at a time
- Bright colors
10. Chicago Metallic 8044 Non-Stick Toaster Oven Bakeware Set, 4-Piece, Carbon Steel
Last on our list is a perfect muffin pan for those that like to do their baking in the toaster oven. This is a four-piece set that comes with everything you need to make some delicious toaster oven muffins.
The size of this pan is 9.5 by 6.25, so it will have no problem fitting in your toaster. You also get a cooling rack, a cake pan, and a baking pan. You won’t be limited to just muffins and cupcakes with the use of this set.
The product is made from heavyweight carbon steel. It cooks very evenly and can handle temperatures up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
The pieces of this set are all considered to be dishwasher safe; however, hand washing is recommended. If you are new to cooking with your toaster oven and you want a simple and easy to use setup this is a great choice.
- Four-piece set
- Easy to use
- Dishwasher safe
- High-quality carbon steel
Things to consider before buying a muffin pan
You may have never realized how many muffin pan options there are on the market. It can be a little overwhelming when you start trying to narrow things down. Luckily there are a few things that you can ask yourself to help make this process a bit easier.
Number of Muffins
Muffin pans are going to be sold in six, twelve, or twenty-four cupcake sizes. You will have to decide if you are cooking for a crowd or if you want to limit the size of the batches you make.
Some people like the smaller muffin tins because they make different flavored muffins in each one. If you are cooking for a crowd, there is no question that the twenty-four muffin size tins are very convenient and will save you quite a bit of time.
Size Of The Muffins
Once you decide how many muffins you want to make, you must also consider the size of the muffin itself. The sizes are usually mini, standard, or jumbo. The jumbo muffin tins sometimes come in the six muffin tray size, but they still take as much better as the standard twelve muffin tin.
Most of the time, the muffin tins will have some areas on the side where you can hold on to get the muffins in and out of the oven. Some of the options in our review, like the Rachel Ray will help by adding a bit of an extra area to grab on.
These will give you some added confidence, especially when dealing with a hot pan.
Cleaning and Care
Almost all of the muffin pans that we reviewed are going to say they are dishwasher safe. Then when you read the next line, they say that you should not put the pan in the dishwasher.
The reason behind this is that the nonstick coating will start to deteriorate over time when used in the dishwasher. To be honest, we find that dishwashers genuinely struggle to get muffin tins clean.
You will end up having to wash twice, and it’s just not worth your time. Take a few minutes and clean the pan with warm water and soap.
Silicone or Steel
As you have probably noticed, muffin pans come in either silicone or steel. The steel is much heavier, and it is the classic method of cooking in a muffin pan. There are positives and negatives to both options.
- Easy to pop muffins out
- Comes in a variety of colors
- Nonstick will not deteriorate over time
- Works well in microwave and dishwasher
- Need to use it on a cookie sheet
- Can sometimes hold onto flavors and oils from food
- Heavy and durable
- Will last a long time
- Does not hold up as well in the dishwasher
- Can’t use in a microwave
- Cooks very evenly
- Pans with the nonstick should release muffins quite easily
- Easier to handle and manage taking in and out of the oven
There were options on our list for less than $10 and those that got closer to $30. When it comes to muffin pans, you are not going to see a significant variance in pricing.
Pay attention to the quality and the construction of the materials and the warranty that is offered. These are the most critical factors to make sure that you are getting a good deal on the proper pan for you.
Most of the steel muffin pans can withstand temperatures up to 500 degrees. The silicone pans will usually be good up to about 475 degrees. There is not too much of a difference, but if you do know that you will be cooking something at 500 degrees, it is best to stick with the steel pans and not run into any trouble.
So, What’s The Best Muffin Pan?
The best muffin pan of 2020 is the AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Muffin Pan. This pan is reasonably priced, cooks evenly, and cleans up within seconds. Not to mention that when you purchase this pack, you get two muffin pans for the price it will cost you for just one from other companies.
If you like to make a lot of muffins and you want something durable, long-lasting, and high quality, we love this option, and we use it in our kitchens.